The criminalisation of young people

Just as the Brfitish Government's promise to protect us from the world of terrorism internationally appears to continue to backfire, the demonisation of the young is a result of poicy to deal with anti-social behaviour. This is not to say that such behaviour should be tolerated, rather the need to recognise the counter-productive results that simply locking young people up is having. Young people already at risk: mental health problems, autism and such problems they may face is being dealt with in a totally inappropriate way. Political responses to appease a public opinion which is based on fear of crime and terror are misguided and damaging. Rather than leading to solutions to problems, they exacerbate the situation. It is in prisons that anti-social ideas are circulated. One young Muslim picked up an extreme view of his religion not in a camp in Afghanistan or Pakistan but in a young offender's institution.

Just as foreign policy is off the rails, so policies at home, presented with every good intention, is leading to greater instability in society, not less. Mental health provision has been recognised as being grossly inadequate for a long time. Health Trust we learn are diverting their resources intended for this to help balance their budgets. Social Services struggle to keep up with demand. Yet there is a high cost to stuffing prisons and young offenders' institutions full to breaking point. This entails cell sharing where a high profile case has shown what can happen to a young person at risk. This has ended up with high suicide rates and incidents of self harm at unprecedented levels.

Research which has evaluated the negative effect of policy must be taken into account as a matter of urgency. It would certainly be helpful if future policy could be informed by humane considerations rather than the pressing demands for retribution and punishment.

A letter from Pauline Cambell whose daughter died the day after she was admitted to prison spells out the problem, as does another from someone in the youth offending service who raises his deep concerns.

Posted by John Tyrrell at August 20, 2006 9:40 AM

Comments

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?